Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR): Key Differences Explained

The EU Blue Card and Permanent Residency (PR) are both documents that allow a skilled professional to work and settle in Germany. They seem to serve the same purpose, but they are not the same. In this Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR) blog, we will discuss the features offered by these documentations and explain the key differences between them.

Get the best mentors on the internet to teach you German! Join the Entri German language course!

Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR): Introduction

Germany is one of the countries that is in the top ten list of every professional seeking international opportunity. It has a strong economy, excellent work-life balance, and plenty of long-term settlement opportunities. This is exactly what many skilled professionals are looking for. The documents that non-EU professionals achieve this are the EU Blue Card and Permanent Residency (PR). These are the settlement permits that help them build a life in an EU country like Germany. Both these permits allow one to work and live legally in Germany. But they differ drastically in many aspects, such as:

• Purpose
• Duration
• Flexibility
• Long-term security

The main difference is that the EU Blue Card is intended for highly skilled professionals entering the German job market, whereas permanent residency is meant for people who dream of indefinitely settling in Germany. Many professionals start with an EU Blue Card and then later transition to Permanent Residency (PR). In this guide, we will discuss the important differences, like eligibility criteria, benefits, application process, etc., for each of these permits. We will also discuss the common mistakes people make while applying for these applications. We hope to help you choose between these two on your path of choosing the best option for your career and long-term plans in Germany.

What is the EU Blue Card?

The first question that needs to be answered here is what exactly an EU Blue Card is. The EU Blue Card is a temporary residence and work permit in EU nations. But there is a catch. It is issued to only highly qualified non-EU professionals. This residence permit is employer-linked. It is designed to attract global talent to Germany’s labour market. Let us first discuss the eligibility criteria one needs to fulfil to apply for an EU Blue Card. If you need this permit, then you must have the following things.

• A recognised degree from a recognised university. (or a comparable qualification)
• A binding job offer or employment contract from your employer in Germany
• A minimum annual gross salary of €45,300 if you are to work in regular professions and that of €41,041 if you are to work in shortage occupations (IT, engineering, mathematics, doctors, scientists)

The Blue Card is generally issued in the following manner.

• For up to 4 years
• For the duration of your employment contract plus three months.

Key Features of the EU Blue Card

Some key features of an EU Blue Card are:

• Temporary residence tied to skilled employment
• Faster route to permanent residency (21–33 months)
• Easier family reunification (no German required initially)
• Limited mobility within the EU
• Possibility to change employers after a certain period

What is Permanent Residency (PR)?

Permanent Residency (PR) is the residential permit that allows foreign nationals to live, work, and study in Germany indefinitely. If you have PR, then you don’t need visa renewals. The benefit of a PR is that it offers stability and freedom which cannot be offered by temporary permits like EU Blue card. There are certain criteria that you need to fulfil to be eligible for PR. They are

• In the standard route, you will need 5 years of legal residence in Germany.
• If you are an EU Blue Card holder, you will need 33 months of employment and 21 months with B1 German language skills.

PR does not depend on your job, salary or who your employer is. Hence this permit is ideal if you are planning to settle in Germany for a very long term. But keep in mind that unlike an EU Blue Card, a PR does not grant automatic EU-wide work rights or mobility to the possessor.

Key Features of PR

Some key features of PR are:

• Unlimited residence in Germany
• Freedom to change jobs/employers
• No salary restrictions
• Access to most social security benefits
• Greater protection against deportation
• No need for visa renewals
• Foundation for German citizenship

Key Differences: EU Blue Card vs PR

The key differences between EU Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR) are given in the comparison table below.

How to Convert Blue Card to PR?

You might have found that a PR requires you to be a resident of Germany for some time. So, applying for a PR directly will not be a viable option for skilled professionals coming to the country for the first time. What you can do in such a case is apply for an EU blue card first and then later upgrade it to a PR after gaining sufficient eligibility. But one might wonder how they can convert an EU Blue Card to PR. The step-by-step method is given below to simplify things for you.

• Hold a Blue Card for at least 33 months (or 21 months with a B1 level of German proficiency).
• Maintain continuous qualified employment.
• Make mandatory pension contributions and pay pension insurance for the required period.
• Have basic German language proficiency.
• Secure accommodation and health insurance

Documents required for starting the process of converting an EU blue card to a PR are:

• Passport
• EU Blue Card
• Proof of employment
• Proof of salary
• Pension insurance statements
• German language certificate
• Proof of accommodation
• Proof of health insurance

The application process of converting an EU blue card to a PR is as follows.

• Apply at Ausländerbehörde (Foreigners’ Office) with supporting documents.
• Submit required documents
• Attend verification interview
• Receive settlement permit approval

Benefits of Holding a Blue Card

There are certain benefits in holding an EU Blue Card. Some of them are

• Strong recognition among German employers
• Easier entry for skilled professionals
• Faster PR eligibility than other visas
• Higher job flexibility within the EU.
• Family reunification with simplified conditions.
• Recognition across several EU countries.
• Flexibility to plan long-term settlement

Benefits of Permanent Residency

Just like an EU Blue card, PR too have certain benefits.

• Lifetime residence rights, i.e., unlimited stay in Germany.
• No salary or job conditions.
• Freedom to change careers or sectors
• Freedom to start a business
• Eligibility for most public benefits like unemployment and child benefits.
• Easier path to German citizenship (after 6–8 years).
• No need for visa stress or renewals

Which One Should You Choose?

Now you might be wondering which path you must choose. The following table will help you make the right choice.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Some common mistakes done by people when taking residential permit in Germany are:

• Assuming the Blue Card is the same as Permanent Residency.
• Believing the Blue Card is permanent
• Not maintaining salary or job for 21/33 months.
• Missing pension contributions (required for PR).
• Waiting too long to apply for PR even when eligible.
• Changing employers without approval

Learn German from expert mentors in the field! Join the Entri German online course now!

Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR): Conclusion

The information provided in this might have finally helped you to settle the Blue Card Germany vs Permanent Residency (PR) debate that has been going on in your mind for a long time. If you are someone trying to settle and work in Germany for the first time, then definitely the EU Blue Card is the way to go. If you have some period of stay and all other eligibilities in hand, then PR is what you should go for.